The Gilder Lehrman Institute of American History
The Institute For Teachers and Students For Historians The Collection Search:




Back to top

Back to top
Back to top
Back to top




Introduction
Facsimile
Item Description and Credits
Transcription
Suggested Reading
Suggested Reading


Introduction

Within this Section
Overview
Archive of Past Documents

Print this page


A Hundred Years After the Fall: Recollections of the 1906 San Francisco Earthquake


Time and again nature wreaks havoc in unfathomable ways. Across the globe and throughout history we have witnessed tremendous suffering as natural tragedies, such as the 2004 Tsunami and Hurricane Katrina, continue to strike humanity in an unpredictable manner. This April marks the 100th anniversary of San Francisco’s Great Quake of 1906. This newly discovered account of the earthquake written by U.S. Commissioner Silas W. Mack still vividly speaks of the approximately 700 lives lost and efforts to rebuild a city left in shambles (GLC 08697). Accompanying Mack’s solemn letter is a proclamation stating that law enforcement was “authorized [by the city] to KILL any and all persons found engaged in Looting or in the Commission of Any Other Crime.” This broadside, issued by San Francisco Mayor E. E. Schmitz, exemplifies the mass hysteria that occurred following the quake (GLC 04967.01). Both documents illustrate the way in which random disasters continue to capture human curiosity and remind us that, even with the technological advances of the twentieth century, we still have no control over nature’s wrath.

The 1906 quake is the most destructive earthquake on record in North America. The earthquake and the fire that followed left approximately 250,000 people homeless, destroyed 25,000 buildings and resulted in an estimated $350 million in damages. Today that would amount to over $32 billion in reconstruction costs [1].

Krista Rupe, Special Projects Manager
The Gilder Lehrman Collection

1. Amount of damages today was calculated using the unskilled wage index developed by Samuel H. Williamson, "What is the Relative Value?" Economic History Services


Item Description and Credits

GLC 08697, Silas W. Mack to Clara W. Mack, Monterey City, California, 20 April 1906

GLC 04967.01, Eugene E. Schmitz, Broadside, San Francisco, California, 18
April 1906


For more information or to obtain copies, contact Ana Ramirez-Luhrs at reference@gilderlehrman.com or call (212) 787-6616 ext. 209.



Transcription

Download PDF Transcript


Clara W. Mack
Ayers Cliff, P.Q., Canada.
Dear Mother:-
Silas W. Mack to Clara W. Mack
Monterey City, California, 20 April 1906.
Typed letter signed, 3 pages.


I sent you a telegram yesterday worded “no damage whatever at Pacific Grove nor Monterey. All Well”. Most likely it is still in the office at Salinas and, for all I know a letter may reach you first. I might have written before but no mail has yet gone out since the 17th. And I do not know when it will go.

Wednesday, April 18th. Will go down in history as the day of the most terrible calamity the United States, and particularly California, has ever known. I do not feel much like writing about it. Would feel better if I could cry but I cannot.

We were awakened at 5:15 A.M. by the shock of the earthquake. There have been several since I have been in California but only two before this were sufficiently pronounced so that I remember them. They did no damage. This one was much more violent even here and was accompanied by a dreadful rumbling noise and roaring, not particularly loud but coming as it were from mighty forces at war in the distance. The house swayed back and forth, it seemed quite a while but I think not more than 25 seconds, then with a sudden wrench stopped. I had gotten out of bed and rushed to the front door but it was so foggy outside that I could see nothing, the first fog of the season. The shocks continued throughout the day but were so light frequently as to be hardly noticeable. There was not the least damage done in the house and no dishes, vases or anything breakable hurled to the floor. And this was the general experience in Monterey and Pacific Grove.

At the Hotel Del Monte it was different. This establishment had some 40 chimneys, very large and since the introduction of steam for heating, useless but still retained, though there had been talk of removing them, to give the appearance of some baronial castle. These swayed back and forth and when the final wrench came at least one-half of them came toppling over onto the roof and fell with deafening roar to the ground, and the remaining half were so damaged that all of since been removed. Unfortunately there was one chimney towering far above the rest from the tower over the main entrance. This struck the roof and went through into one of the chambers where a bridal couple were sleeping carrying them bedstead and all into the chamber below. He was instantly killed and she has since died. No one else was hurt here.

None of us, for a moment, realized what was going on elsewhere. But as the day wore on we found that we were isolated from the rest of the world. Then parties got through from Salinas and reported over a $1,000,000.00 damage there but all communication from the rest of [2] world still cut off. The enterprise of the great San Francisco newspapers is such that we knew in the afternoon, as the hours sped by and no boats put into port for news, that San Francisco must be having troubles of her own. The papers will tell you the rest.

350,000 people homeless and the number of killed will never be known as they were mostly cremated, or will be when the fire is finally extinguished. The earthquake shattered the watermains and although building after building was blown up by dynamite nothing could stop the progress of the flames. I have talked with several Pacific Grove people who were there and they say that the sight was terrible though the direct effect of the shock was not so noticeable. It was the fire. The great skyscrapers stood the earthquake quite well but fires at once broke out in twenty places, mostly caused by electric wires.

San Francisco is under martial law. As I write the troops are marching out from the Presidio of Monterey to re-inforce those on duty there and also to guard San Jose. The State militia, including Troop “C” of Salinas with Daisy’s brother either first or second in command is also marching North. Thieves and criminals of all descriptions are bent on crime and are being shot on the spot if caught at their work.

The captain of the torpedo-boat destroyer Paul Jones which brought orders here for the troops this morning from Mare Island stated that as he passed out of the Golden Gate S.F. was a wall of fire. The residence portion is now burning. Dr. Goodell and wife were in S.F. and thus far no word from them. She was in a precarious condition anyway and I fear she will not pull through.

We all have many friends, and many of us relatives, in the city and, as you may imagine, the suspense is dreadful. We have not yet scarcely begun to realize the extent of the disaster. Thousands upon thousands of destitute people are headed this way and we must help take care of them. Congress has voted $1,000,000.00 for relief of S.F. but what is that among so many? San Jose, Palo Alto, and other wealthy cities in the line of march, are themselves damaged to a great extent. It is said that Stanford University buildings are nearly all wrecked and $5,000,000.00 will not replace them.

What the effect will be on Monterey and Pacific Grove it is very difficult to say. It may be even beneficial or it may be very injurious. These two towns stand on a peninsula of granite formation and no earthquake is likely to damage them to any great extent..S.F. was build up on sand dunes, or eroded land, which is worse.

[3] There is no doubt, however, that San Francisco will be rebuilt and in a far grander style than before. Building materials of all kinds will go away up in price and labor as well.

Some people are beginning to draw their deposits from local banks and as a good deal of their cash is locked up in safes which are still red hot, they may create a money panic but I trust that this will be prevented by getting in gold from Los Angeles. We have many thousands of dollars in New York but even N.Y. exchange is regarded with suspicion by some of these characters. It is a pity that they could not be shut up a while in the U.S. Mint at San Francisco with millions, millions everywhere but not a drop to drink.

Well, I must close. It will be strange of this letter is very well written as I do not feel at all like writing. The air is very hot and at night we can see the glare of the fire reflected in the northern sky.

The morning of the earthquake I intended to leave on the 7:55 A.M. train to attend the meeting of the Congregational Association of the Santa Clara District and was at the train. The latter is still in the Grove and may be for a long time to come. Miss Clara L. Ewalt, Primary Field Worker of the Ohio State S.S. Association, who as been helping us in the State for three months, was going with me to San Francisco, to get things in readiness for the State S.S. Convention at Santa Rosa next week. She is much distracted as her parents will think she is killed. Santa Rosa, by the way, is reported as wiped out of existence. I hope not.

Now, do not worry as we are no more apt to get killed by earthquake than you are by lightning. Mt. Vesuvius is now repeating the scenes of Pompeii and Herculaneum and in 2000 years San Francisco may be again destroyed. But I expect to move before then.
We are having the upper part of the house finished off so as to get two more fine bedrooms. Daisy is doing her own work for a time until we can get a girl as the one we had was called back to New York State by the illness of her father. Uncle Charlie and family are well and it may be a long time before his enemies get him out of the Post Office.
From your affectionate son,
Silas W. Mack

Notes: The letter is written on stationary of the law office of Silas W. Mack in Pacific Grove and Monterey.



Suggested Reading

Bronson, William, The Earth Shook, The Sky Burned : A Photographic Record of the 1906 San Francisco Earthquake and Fire. San Francisco: Chronicle Books LLC, 1996.

Burkhart, David, Earthquake Days: The 1906 San Francisco Earthquake & Fire in 3-D. San Francisco: Faultline Books, 2005.

Fradkin, Philip L., The Great Earthquake and Firestorms of 1906 : How San Francisco Nearly Destroyed Itself. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2005.

Fradkin, Philip L. et al, After the Ruins, 1906 and 2006 : Rephotographing the San Francisco Earthquake and Fire. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2006.

Hansen, Gladys and Condonm, Emmet, Denial of Disaster: The Untold Story and Photographs of the San Francisco Earthquake and Fire or 1906. California: Cameron & Company, 1989.

Nolte, Carl, The San Francisco Century : A City Rises from the Ruins of the 1906 Earthquake and Fire. San Francisco: San Francisco Chronicle, 2005.













The Collection Newly Discovered Documents Current Featured Document